Over the 2016 and 2017 fiscal years, taxpayers have seen a loss of 400 billion rupees from the publicsector banks, with all of them losing money except sbi. For value investors, a low pb ratio is the classic indication of an undervalued stock. Consolidation among public sector banks speech by mr r gandhi, deputy governor of the reserve bank of india, at the mint south banking enclave, bangalore, 22 april 2016. The indian government and the countrys central bank are at the final stage of drawing up a plan to infuse rs2. Stocks trading below their book value can give decent. Pdf corporate governance of public sector banks in india. Master of business administration i declare that the presented thesis represents largely my own ideas and work in my own words. Among public sector banks, only state bank of indias oneyear forward pricetobook value is higher than 1.
We maintain our negative stance on public sector banks psb in the near term on the back of book value dilution by 832 per cent at current. Book value represents an important valuation for bank stocks because banks are typically analyzed in different fashion than stocks in other sectors. Pricetobook ratios have been unusually low for many banks since the. This is because most public sector banks have bloated bad loans and very few of them are actually growing the loan books. The losses would be even higher not accounting sbis profits but we dont know how bad the situation is. If we have good large banks, such banks can tap these opportunities and can become global banks. Objectives of research a comparative study of performance of public sector bank and private sector bank has been made by keeping in view, the following objectives 1. The dismal state of indias public sector banks prev next s ince these banks are mostly trading below their book value, any capital raise will dilute book value and earnings. May 19, 2009 public sector banks psbs continue to outperform private banks in terms of book value. If that is done now, the sale of the government stake will fetch money. For more detailed updates, read our banks private sector pvt report and check the latest banks private sector pvt results.
Assistance provided by shri santosh pandey is gratefully acknowledged. Learn what the average pricetobook pb ratio is in the banking industry and how the corporate stock evaluation metric is used when. Public sector banks psbs are a bone stuck in the throat of the government, which can neither swallow them nor throw them out. The government feels that most public sector banks are now ready to expand their core banking business as the stress is behind them, said another official. A study on customer satisfaction towards public and. Hence, bank of america corporations pricetobook ratio for the period was 1.
Jun 25, 2019 the pricetobook pb ratio is an evaluation metric that is used to compare the current market price of a companys stock to its book value. Customer is king in market by adam smith suggest that in this competitive era of service industry customer hold power to choose the best and having maximum. There are a total of 12 public sector banks alongside 1 stateowned payments bank in india. Jul 24, 2018 all of these factors suggest that, despite the shortterm bottom, public sector banks are still a sector of the market we want to be fading strength in rather than buying weakness. Pricetobook value ratio of stateowned banks jumped from 0. Public sector banks psbs are a major type of bank in india, where a majority stake i. The borrowers represented the micro, small and medium sized enterprises msmes, retail, agriculture and corporate sectors, which was indicative of an economic revival, said finance minister nirmala sitharamans office in a tweet on thursday. In simple terms it would be the amount of money that a share holder would get if a company were to liquidate.
Here are the latest stock price details of indias top banks private sector pvt stocks. The alarming state of public sector bankspart 2 in the 5 year period from fy15 to fy19, central bank of india has incurred a total net loss of about rs 14,000 crores. Among public sector banks, only state bank of indias oneyear forward priceto book value is higher than 1. We also find that public banks and foreign banks tend to have higher market value. Dec 18, 2019 the 10 best bank stocks to buy for 2020. Public sector banks choke on bad loan mess business. To check the expectations and the satisfaction levels regarding the various services quality dimensions between public and private sector banks. It sells of all its assets, and pays off all its debts.
View banks public sector nse stocks quoting at a steep discount to its book value. Their decline started during the late 90s, after the emergence of private sector banks. Mar 20, 2018 but such a move would also need to be accompanied by eliminating the statutory liquidity ratio slr for the banks and by reducing public ownership in the banking system. Read more about valuation gap between public sector and private banks narrows on business standard. Among the six leading banks, only industry leader jpmorgan chase jpm and bank. Aug 12, 2017 price to book is a favorite of value investors as it gives a good indication of the relation of the book value of the company about its price. Bad loans exceed market value of public sector banks.
Are bank stock investors ready for lower dividends and. Taxpayers lose massive rs 98,900 crore in public sector banks psbs. In case of public sector undertaking psu banks, if loans that face the risk of being declared non. The market gain and continued reinterest in the financial sector was the. Thus we can see that right now the time is ripe for consolidation in the public sector bank space. In comparison, bad loans of private sector banks are just about 6. Find out why bank stocks usually trade below book value and understand how trading activities increase banks risk exposures and affect. That was strong stock buybacks, rising dividends and a steadily rising book value per share. State bank of india, the largest bank, has balance sheet size which is roughly 17 times the size of smallest public sector bank. Objectives of research a comparative study of performance of public sector bank and private sector bank has been.
Psu bank stocks fall up to 12% on earnings, asset quality worries. As of 31 march 2019, the total amount of loans given out by indian banks was rs 98. A comparison between nine private sector banks operating in the country and 23 psbs shows that psbs. Sarkari vs private bank economic survey 2020 pdf says. Valuation gap between public sector and private banks. How to figure the book value of bank stock finance zacks. Warren buffett states in every annual shareholder letter that he writes the book value of berkshire hathaway as a way of keeping score.
However, banking system continues to be dominated by public sector banks psbs which still have more than 70 per cent market share of the banking system assets. Get list of bse company name, last price, % chg, book. Most of the banks have been generating low to midteen returns on tangible book. A public bank, like a private bank, can take tax revenues and other government income as deposits, create money in the form of bank credit, and lend at very low interest rates. A great way to find undervalued companies is to look at the price to book ratio, anything under a one is considered undervalued in correlation to its equity. The dismal state of indias public sector banks rediff. Public sector banks department of financial services. Banks public sector nse stocks discount to book value. The desirability of consolidation in indian banking sector is widely felt across the spectrum.
But when a crisis is systemic, and the financial system freezes, the bailout hits the taxpayer whether the problem is caused by public or private banks. Market capitalisation of bank of baroda, which also has asset book and total deposits many times that of ausfb, is also roughly the same as that of small finance lender. Entering 2019, bank stocks were expected to have a good year on wall street, as interest rates seemed destined to head higher. Public sector banks psbs dominate the banking sector in india with about threequarters of banking assets. The secondlargest public sector bank has a welldiversified book with 32% exposure to overseas markets. There are at present times several congruent factors that indicate that consolidation in indian banking scene has its right time. The bjp government has little faith in a vibrant public sector being. Financial services covers the functioning of banks, financial institutions, insurance companies and the national pension system javascript is a standard programming language that is included to provide interactive features, kindly enable javascript in your browser. Steady govt capital infusion does little as public sector. Investors are scouting an unlikely corner of the stock market. Know more about banking sector in uk and offering by banks. Growth investors are likely to consider investing in promising regional banks. Emphasis has been placed on exploring and identifying the underlined issues of competition for the banking professional in general and public sector banks in particular. The empirical findings revealed that, out of nine independent variables used.
Book value per share is an accounting measure based on historical transactions. The share of the total business of banking sector in india held by the public sector banks continued to grow through the 1980s and 90s, and psu banks accounted for 90% of the total banking sectors business. Unlike other psu banks, the market share of the bank rose between 200607. Mar 03, 2020 the government feels that most public sector banks are now ready to expand their core banking business as the stress is behind them, said another official. We may bite the bullet and draw up plans for privatisation. That shows private sector banks are having less deposits and accounts of people residing in anantapur dist then of public sector banks. Do accounting numbers have any relation with stock prices. The pb ratio is favored by value investors for its. Public sector banks psbs continue to outperform private banks in terms of book value. In comparison, psbs had made fresh loans on a net basis of rs 1. Psbs outperform private sector banks in 0809 book value. Stocks trading below their book value can give decent returns. The private sector banks and the public sector banks are differentiated mainly on the basis of the persons who are holding its majority of the shares where in case of the private sector banks majority of shares are held by the private individuals and corporations whereas in case of the public sector banks, majority of shares are.
Valuation gap between public sector and private banks narrows. Sarkari vs private bank economic survey 2020 pdf says this. The shares of these banks are listed on stock exchanges. How to effectively run a public sector bank the hindu. The methodology used in this study is panel data analysis. The private sector banks and the public sector banks are differentiated mainly on the basis of the persons who are holding its majority of the shares where in case of the private sector banks majority of shares are held by the private individuals and corporations whereas in case of the public sector banks, majority of shares are held by the government. The impact of csr spending on the financial performance of. Difference between private and public sector banks. However, such examples are not many in public sector banks sphere. The bjp government has little faith in a vibrant public sector being able to deliver value to the economy, which it wants on a rapid growth path.
His thoughts on the importance of book value versus intrinsic value were laid out in his berkshire 1993 letter. For now, it would be better to establish an independent department in the finance ministry to handle both internal and external debt reporting directly to the finance minister. Whatever is left over is the book value of the company. A public bank might be capitalized through an initial investment by the city or state, as well as through tax and fee revenue.
Bankinfouk banking information portal in the united kingdom. The banks profitability ratios have steadily declined during the last 5 years. In contrast, every rupee of investor money invested in new. The price to book value ratio, or pbv ratio, compares the market and book value of the company. A comparative study between private sector banks and public sector banks with respect to cachar district degree for which the thesis is submitted. In contrast to the psbs, public money invested in private sector banks set up after 1991 gained 9. Comparative study between public sector banks and private sector banks in atm, internet banking, telephone banking, mobile banking problems of technology usage. Consolidation in indian banking system in the past 12. Price book value ratio pbv or pb ratio equitymaster. Comparative study of performance of public and private. Dec 15, 2019 as of 31 march 2019, the total amount of deposits in the indian banking system was rs 125.
A year later, in march, 1992, the combined total of branches held by public sector banks was 60,646 across india, and deposits accounted for. The study is focused mainly on 25 banks which includes both public and private sector banks. Comparative study between private sector and public sector. Learn what the average pricetobook pb ratio is in the banking industry and how the corporate stock evaluation metric is used when analyzing banks.
Most psbs in india are classic, plain vanilla deposittakers and loanmakers. The share of the banking sector held by the public banks continued to grow through the 1980s, and by 1991 public sector banks accounted for 90% of the banking sector. Priceto book value ratio of stateowned banks jumped from 0. Many of them are trading at half of their book value. Over the past week or so, weve seen an upside reversal in many of the public sector bank. The severity of the selloff in large private sector banks such as hdfc bank. Book value can refer to several ways to analyze a business, but when it comes to bank stocks, the book value pertains to the net asset value of the company. Public sector banks psbs saw their loan book shrink for the first time in at least two decades as advances fell by rs 1. Also a good place for those who plans to build their career in banking sector. Here are 10 of the best picks in the financial sector, including the best bank stocks to buy. Consolidation among public sector banks of psbs would be spelt out. The reserve bank has been given powers under section 44a of banking regulation act 1949 to approve such voluntary mergers. Comparative study of performance of public and private sector.
528 374 277 1229 207 1493 1250 540 1326 947 231 412 605 416 849 1268 143 1327 1314 663 1460 1404 1125 1491 179 178 927 755 1321 601 1040 350 269 1273 336 1101 84 1324 825